Fanatics, Fanatics! They Abound! | The Violent Bear It Away | Book Review
“FROM THE DAYS OF JOHN THE BAPTIST UNTIL NOW, THE KINGDOM OF HEAVEN SUFFERETH VIOLENCE, AND THE VIOLENT BEAR IT AWAY.” Matthew 11:12
In the first chapter of this book, there is an image of an old man ranting at his adopted son, who he actually kidnapped, while he sits in a coffin that he had built for himself when it was his time to die. This image is still with me, probably because it is the quintessential Southern Gothic image. While Donald Ray Pollack is the first Southern Gothic writer that I reviewed, and I only came around to The Violent Bear It Away now, I technically read a short story by Flannery O'Connor when I was in high school. All that I remember of it was a father selling his retarded daughter to some creep, only for the creep to abandon her at a bar; something like that. This story is quite similar, and I imagine that when I reread that story, and I will, I'll recognize it.
The Violent Bear It Away is about a fourteen-year-old boy, Tarwater, who struggles with purpose in his life, when his great uncle, the old man, passes away. He decides to return to his uncle Rayber, who was also taken by the great uncle once, but who has violently rejected everything that the great uncle ever told him. The great uncle is a fantical Christian, and a self-declared prophet, who is obsessed with baptising everyone and everything. The uncle, then, is a secular man, someone who has rejected the faith entirely. This book captures the tension between Christianity, particularly Protestantism, and secularism inside the boy. In which direction will he decide to go with his life? The old man has tasked him with baptising the retarded son of the uncle Rayber, and the uncle wants to resist this, instead bringing Tarwater around to his way of thinking.
Structure
The structure of the novel was very strange, but it was also primarily in the beginning that I noticed this. Namely, the first chapter had a structure that was very stream of consciousness. It was told mainly from the perspective of the boy, but it readily slipped in and out of the present and the past, giving insight on the main events throughout the story. It reminded me of a story told in a stream of consciousness, letting the story amble about until it is strung together a series of interspersed events over the course of a whole lifetime. And this was primarily the case for the first chapter, but less so in the later chapters. And I learned not long afterward that the first chapter used to be a short story called You Can't Be Any Poorer Than Dead. The first chapter is also much longer than the other chapters in the book. It has subdivisions, but I remember thinking that it took a while to get through. It also provided a full narrative, of a kind. You get a real sense of the characters and the situation by the end of it, and it sets up the rest of the novel really well.
Atmosphere
As with any Southern Gothic novel, the strongest aspect is the atmosphere, which is encapsulated by its setting, dialogue, characters, and themes, all at once. The characters are flawed in any manner of ways, the content is often violent, the themes involve religion, and it is unapologetic in every respect. It shows what human beings are, warts and all, and it does it in a context that feels so well-realized, that you feel that you could be living there. As I mentioned in the beginning, the old man ranting at his teenage son while seated in a coffin is one of the great images.
Theme and Character
The theme requires special focus, as there are central themes around Christianity. The central conflict is between Tarwater and his uncle. In a way, you could say that the central conflict is between Uncle Rayber and the old man. The old man has recruited Tarwater to baptize Bishop, the retarded son of Rayber, and another conflict takes place within Tarwater, given his hesitancy over whether he wants to carry out the old man's will or not. But the thematic conflict is over religiosity and secularism. As I mentioned above, the old man is Christianity and Uncle Rayber is secularism.
The old man is a religious fanatic. He is genuinely a raving lunatic who tries to kidnap multiple children so he can raise them in accordance with faith. He is the type of man with such conviction that nothing will ever convince him otherwise. At one point, he was placed in an institution, though my impression was that this was an abuse of power.
Uncle Rayber is also a fanatic in his own way. People might be predisposed to seeing him as the logical one, given that he gave up his religion and represents the secular life—but he is as fanatical as the old man. Indeed, he is the inversion of him. There is one point in the novel where he is watching a church service, and a child is speaking before the service, and he thinks about kidnapping the child to shield it from the religion. "Rayber saw himself fleeing with the child to some enclosed garden where he would teach her the truth, where he would gather all the exploited children of the world and let the sunshine flood their minds." These purported tactics are obviously familiar, but the secular convictions go further than merely *not Christian*. The relationship to Christianity is shaped by his life as a prior convert who was taken by the old man at a much younger age. This Youtube comment summarizes it quite succinctly: “The school teacher essentially reinvented his own secular religion bent on salvation from his uncle's form of Christianity.”
But Rayber's secularism takes it a step further. His relationship to his son, Bishop, is another defining feature. And because he does not subscribe to the Christian view that human life is sacred, he has trouble loving his son, given that his son has mental retardation. He has very complex feelings about the child, and his inner psychology and reflection on the child are quite revealing. This quote from the text helps capture the complexity quite well: "Without warning his hated love gripped him and held him in a vise. He should have known better than to let the child onto his lap." He hates him and he loves him.
I haven't arrived at the main character, Tarwater. This is because Tarwater is caught between these two men. He has no guiding principle yet. The old man has placed one on his shoulders, but it has the predictable response from a young man still trying to figure himself out.
Theme
Through this character set up, we see the thematic conflict play out.
Now, as an atheist, I cannot say that I am a staunch advocate for what O'Connor believes. But, at the same time, I can't claim to be a humanist or adherent to some other popular form of ethics subscribed to by atheists. I am philosophically amoral. I think morality is a social delusion that we cannot escape, even if you understand what it is—and I think we are religious by nature. The idea that the secular man was a religious zealot of his own is actually quite consonant with my beliefs. I also think abortion should be an option for mentally retarded people. I know Peter Singer, a notable Utilitarian, thinks that post-birth abortions should be allowed for infants, if the disability is severe enough. Unfortunately, for the secularists, this book is actually fairly close to the truth.
At the same time, I think there is a legitimate point to be made by "secularists" who would point out that the concept of being secular essentially denotes *not Christian.* Because of that, there is not necessarily any positive content to the concept, and the degree to which any conclusions can be extrapolated are questionable. The book is still functional, given that Rayber has his personal "religion" specified—and I stand by what I said above—yet this should still be noted.
I do find the story rather strange, of course. This is not normal Christian fiction. It is not happy, it is not uplifting. It is mired in the muck of real human life, especially the deranged and even the depraved kind. The religious are spared nothing. In any other context, I might think this book was a lampoon of Christianity. But in the end, the idea is a bit more complex than that. It is well captured by this quote from O'Connor, herself, "I think it is safe to say that while the South is hardly Christ-centered, it is most certainly Christ-haunted." This is a rather eloquent way of putting it. She is writing about a region that has a troubled relationship with the religion that she considers to be true. She makes a nuanced point about the difference between the truth and how people take on that truth. The South is nominally Christian, but it is more window dressing than it is characteristic. (It's also worth noting that she was Catholic, and critical of southern Protestantism, though this is not explicit.)
It is in this Southern context that O'Connor chooses to write, and to express thoughts on theology. The result is great, as it has the ability to appeal to a wide audience, without seeming preachy or annoying, like most Christian fiction.
Ending
The ending of the novel is violent and disturbing, but it is also loaded with thematic meaning. Tarwater comes to a point where his attempts to escape his bestowed destiny reaches a certain irony. And this is done with the most horrible act in the novel. Religiosity and secularism intersect, in a way, with religion acting as the cleansing force.
And the secular worldview is not only compared to the religious one, throughout, but it is ultimately shown to be shallow with Rayber's realization in the very end.
Conclusion
Overall, I have to say that this was a very satisfying and entertaining read. I think I will give it an 8/10.
Video: https://youtu.be/SsLFpNEMoho
Comments
Post a Comment